Skip to Main Content
It looks like you're using Internet Explorer 11 or older. This website works best with modern browsers such as the latest versions of Chrome, Firefox, Safari, and Edge. If you continue with this browser, you may see unexpected results.

Writing 39C Information Literacy Tutorial - 2019 version

Source Differentiation

You will want to consider many types of information sources as you write your paper, including information written with a scholarly audience in mind as well as information written for the general population. Each type of information serves a different purpose, and has its own benefits and limitations.

This video shows how popular (non-peer-reviewed) and scholarly (peer-revieiwed) sources have different audiences, contexts, and purposes. You should incorporate many types of sources into your Contexts Project paper. 

Popular and Scholarly Sources: The Information Cycle (CSUSB Library) [time=3:57]

 

"Scholarly vs. Popular"

Often, we are presented with a binary of "scholarly vs. popular" information sources. The reality is that there is a spectrum of types of sources. However, here are some basic things to keep in mind:

  • "Scholarly" = Peer Reviewed. These are academic sources for an academic audience, written by academics, and have undergone a very specific and rigorous process of peer review. They have these characteristics:
    • Purpose: To present original research, often very specific in scope.
    • Language: Formal, academic writing, often using a style determined by the academic discipline.
    • Cited Sources: Essential. May be in the form of a References section, endnotes, or footnotes.
    • Author Information: The author is always listed, and their university or institutional affiliation is also often provided.
  • "Popular" = Non-Peer-Reviewed. These are things written for the general population. Note that "popular" in this context does not imply that it is well-known, well-liked, in demand, etc. It simply means that it has not gone through a peer review process. There are many credible sources that are "popular," including government documents, research reports by institutes, policy papers, investigative journalism, and more. 
    • Purpose: To inform the general population about a topic, issue, or idea.
    • Language: Usually everyday language, although some may be written for a more technical, specialized, or professional audience.
    • Cited Sources: Sometimes, but not always. 
    • Author Information: The author's name is often provided, but not always.